95 Hilltop Lane, McKinleyville, CA 95519 - Single Family Home

$ 1,649,000 On the Market Save to FavoritesSaved      

Description:

Are you looking for a home that feels like you are on vacation every day? 95 Hilltop Lane in Blue Lake is a rare retreat-style estate surrounded by towering redwoods with sweeping valley and ridgeline views. Enjoy antique hardwood floors, Wolf appliances, indoor/outdoor surround sound, expansive patios, covered outdoor living, sport court, bocce court, water feature, electric gate, cameras, and parking for 30+ cars. Private, refined, recreational, and unforgettable. Set among towering redwoods with sweeping valley, forest, and ridgeline views, 95 Hilltop Lane in Blue Lake offers a rare retreat-style setting designed for privacy, comfort, recreation, security, and indoor-outdoor living. From the moment you arrive through the electric gate, the property feels peaceful and intentional, with landscaped pathways, curated hardscape, exterior lighting, a running water feature, manicured trees, and multiple gathering areas that make the home feel like a private resort. The home has a warm, refined lodge-style feel with antique hardwood floors custom milled from wood dating back more than 150 years and sourced from the East Coast. Custom lighting, stone accents, barn doors, wood details, generous living areas, and large windows create a rich yet comfortable setting that connects naturally to the surrounding redwoods and outdoor living spaces. The kitchen is beautifully finished with white cabinetry, a large center island, tile backsplash, pendant lighting, generous counter space, and premium Wolf cooking appliances that elevate the space beyond ordinary stainless finishes. A built-in Wolf warm beverage maker adds another layer of everyday luxury. The nearby dining and living areas flow naturally to patios, decks, and covered outdoor spaces, making the home ideal for everyday living, holidays, and larger-scale entertaining. An immersive indoor/outdoor surround sound system extends the entertainment experience from the main living areas to the outdoor gathering spaces. Enjoy music on the patios, game day under the covered pavilion, outdoor dinners, movie nights, parties, or quiet evenings with sound flowing naturally inside and out. Multiple living spaces provide flexibility for family, guests, work, hobbies, media, and extended stays. The primary suite feels like a private retreat of its own, with warm wood flooring, a distinctive decorative ceiling treatment, spacious bedroom area, walk-in closet, wood stove, and an impressive ensuite bath with dual vanities and a large tiled shower. Additional bedrooms and baths offer practical flexibility while maintaining the home's warm, cohesive character. Outdoor living is where this property truly shines. Expansive patios, view decks, lawn areas, and covered gathering spaces surround the home, creating multiple places to relax, dine, entertain, and enjoy the setting. The covered outdoor kitchen and lounge area features exposed timber framing, Wolf outdoor cooking appliances, built-in prep and bar space, comfortable gathering areas, lighting, and beautiful views through the trees. The grounds are designed for both relaxation and recreation, with a fenced sport court, bocce court, turf recreation area, trampoline/play area, landscaped pathways, rock features, lawn space, and multiple seating areas tucked among the redwoods. Every tree on the property has been intentionally manicured for health, purpose, and presentation, giving the entire setting a polished, cared-for feel. The property also offers practical and lifestyle features that are difficult to duplicate, including parking for 30+ vehicles, a full-property camera system, metal roof, copper gutters, on-demand hot water, and extensive custom drainage improvements throughout the property. A fenced approximately 1-acre lower pasture area with horse shelter/stall provides added flexibility for buyers who may want room for a horse, hobby use, or a more expansive country-estate lifestyle. Every part of this property feels intentional: morning coffee by the water feature, sunsets through the trees, outdoor dinners under the pavilion, games on the court, music flowing inside and out, quiet walks through the landscaped grounds, and peaceful moments surrounded by redwoods. This is more than a home; it is a private Blue Lake retreat built for connection, comfort, recreation, entertaining, security, and memorable Humboldt living.

All 73 Photos



Virtual Tour
Open Virtual Tour

Virtual Tour
Open Virtual Tour

Quick Facts

Bedrooms:
3
Baths:
2
Total Rooms:
8
Area:
2351 sq ft
Style:
Custom
Condition:
Excellent
Year Built:
1979
Lot Size:
4.00 acres
Garage:
None
Est. Payment:
$8338 / month
(20% down, 30 years @ 6.5%)
Asking Price:
$ 1,649,000
Days on Market:
1
Listing Office:
New Wave Realty & Financial Services
Listing Agent:
Mark Bickmore
Contact:
Ming Tree, Realtors
707-445-4500

Have questions? Not finding what you want? Ask us and we'll find it for you!


    Interior Features:

  • Levels: One
  • Laundry: 220, Dryer Hookup, Washer Hookup
  • General: Whirlpool, Deck Off, Pantry, Breakfast Bar, Ceiling Fan(s), Dining Nook, Sound System, Dining in Kitchen
  • Eco/Green Features: Solar Panels, Permeable Walkways
  • Heating: Gas Stove, Propane, Forced Air, Woodstove
  • Flooring: Hardwood
  • Exterior Features:

  • Style: Custom
  • Condition: Excellent
  • Garage: None, 0
  • RV Parking: Yes
  • Construction Features:

  • Foundation: Concrete Perimeter
  • Roofing: Metal
  • Lot Features:

  • View: Panoramic, Hills, Pasture, Woods, Mountain View
  • Fencing: Fully
  • Location Features:

  • Road/Access: Paved
  • Utilities Features:

  • Water: Public
  • Sewer: Private Sewer
  • Walk Score®: 2 Car-Dependent - Almost all errands require a car
  • Transit Score®: 0 Minimal Transit - It is possible to get on a bus
Coming Soon.


Neighborhood details for 95 Hilltop Lane, McKinleyville, CA 95519

HousingNear HereCity
Total Households2917630
Median Age of Home19701981
Median Property Value$400,000$333,632
Homes Owner Occupied66.14%62.46%
Homes Rented33.86%37.54%
Homes Vacant12.71%4.84%
Median Rent$ 819$ 837
Crime Risk (national avg is 100)Near HereCity
Overall Crime Risk181139
Murder Risk180151
Assault Risk148116
Burglary Risk94111
Vehicle Theft Risk119136
PeopleNear HereCity
Population58017553
Male55.17%50.01%
Female44.83%49.99%
Median Age47.938.9
People Per Household2.522.66
Households with Children66.93%63.53%
Median Household Income$61,500$50,606
EducationNear HereCity
Some High School2.26%7.03%
High School23.02%22.87%
Associate Degree5.64%9.68%
Bachelors Degree20.32%18.13%
Masters Degree8.13%6.49%
Graduate Degree12.19%8.88%
Professional Degree3.84%1.41%
Doctorate Degree0.23%0.98%
CommutingNear HereCity
Average commute time25 minutes18 minutes
Travel by Car80.19%90.57%
Travel by Public Transportation0.0%0.71%
Travel by Walking0.62%2.47%
Travel by Other3.41%0.38%
Work from Home15.79%4.63%
WeatherNear HereCity
Average Annual temperature54 degrees53 degrees
Average Annual minimum43 degrees44 degrees
Average Annual maximum64 degrees63 degrees
January Average Low38 degrees38 degrees
July Average High74 degrees70 degrees
Sunny Days per Year186 days186 days
Partly Clear Days per Year78 days78 days
Cloudy Days per Year7 days7 days
Rainy Days per Year117 days117 days
Snowy Days per Year0 days0 days
Annual Rainfall68.0 in.60.4 in.
Annual Snowfall0 in.0 in.
Environmental (national avg is 100)Near HereCity
Pollution Index9996
Earthquake Index541696
Wind Index31
Hurricane Index00
Tornado Index30
Hail Index00

Contact a Ming Tree Agent


Based on information from the Humboldt Association of REALTORS®, as of 06/13/2026. All data, including all measurements and calculations of area, is obtained from various sources and has not been, and will not be verified by broker or MLS for accuracy. All information should be independently reviewed and verified of accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Copyright ©2026 Humboldt Association of Realtors®. All rights reserved.